The pros and cons of fixed vs variable energy tariffs
There's often a lot of debate about choosing between fixed and variable tariffs, and there are advantages and disadvantages to both. This is my take on the pros and cons of both options.
Fixed Tariffs
A fixed tariff locks in your energy prices for a set period of time (12 or 18 months usually) so you'll know what you're paying, but they do have exit fees and your prices won't go down if the Ofgem Price Cap drops below the rates you fixed at.
Pros:
- You know exactly what you'll be paying for your unit rates and standing charges for the duration of your fix
- Fixed rates can be lower than the Ofgem Price Cap, and if you fix before price increases, you can keep your energy costs lower
Cons:
- Fixed tariffs usually have exit fees that are at least £75 each for gas and electricity, so if you change supplier during the fix, you could be on the hook for £150.
- When wholesale prices go down, your fixed tariff won't, so you could end up paying more for your energy in the long run. Some suppliers do allow you to switch between fixed tariffs during the duration of your fix, but others don't, so make sure you read the small print.
Variable Tariffs
Variable, standard, or flexible tariffs have no exit fees so you can change suppliers without penalties, but they do go up and down in line with the Ofgem Price Cap.
Pros:
- You're not locked into your supplier, so you can change suppliers as many times as you want, and take advantage of referral and switching bonuses.
- Your unit rates are updated quarterly, and the Ofgem Price Cap makes sure there's a maximum amount per unit that you will pay.
Cons:
- In turbulent times, the Ofgem Price Cap, which sets your unit rates on a variable tariff, can increase significantly, as we have seen with the wars in Ukraine and Iran. It goes up quickly, but is very slow to come down.
- You're rewarded less for sticking with your supplier. The best tariffs and unit rates are only available to customers who stick with their suppliers for the long term by taking on a fix.
Which option is right for me?
To be fair to both options, there are clear pros and cons to each, but ultimately, it's about predictability vs flexibility. I'm happy with my energy supplier, their service, and the 18-month fixed tariff that they offered me. Before that, I was happy to stick with a flexible tariff.
The fix that I recently opted for was lower than the market rate for October 2026, and well below the predicted rise for January 2027, but saying that, who knows in 12 months' time if I've made the right decision. If the price cap drops below my fixed rates, there'll be little that I can do to take advantage of that.
Which option will you choose?